Justice for Nolan Wells · Chapter 02
Why the official story does not hold
The argument
Jackson County closed this case on the strength of one word: drowning. Two pathologists refused to write that word. The grand jury's own report admits it was reached by elimination, from a body too decomposed to test, with a head injury nobody can explain. Everything else rests on the accounts of the people who left him on the island, and their own messages show them asking where he was, deleting conversations, and discussing lawyers.
This page does not accuse anyone of a crime. No one has been charged, and the grand jury found no credible evidence of one. What it does is set the official story next to the record, line by line, and let you decide whether "drowning, case closed" is an answer or an exit.
The official story
Sources: ABC News, grand jury report, ABC News, July 27, Mississippi Free Press, PBS NewsHour, Oxygen, CNN timeline, LAmag
Side by side
Drowning
If this were a solved drowning
A finding, backed by evidence
What the record actually says
A diagnosis of exclusion. The grand jury's own report says it was reached "by process of elimination" and that decomposition made even that harder.
Sources: ABC News, grand jury report
The cause of death
If this were a solved drowning
Determined
What the record actually says
Undetermined. Twice. The state medical examiner and an independent pathologist with no ties to Mississippi both declined to call it drowning.
Sources: ABC News, Oct. 5, Mississippi Free Press
The head injury
If this were a solved drowning
Explained
What the record actually says
Unexplained. Two dark red-purple bruises under the scalp on the back of his head, in both autopsies. The report says how he got them "remains unclear."
Sources: ABC News, Oct. 5, ABC News, grand jury report
Intoxication
If this were a solved drowning
Measured
What the record actually says
Unmeasurable. Toxicology was "not particularly informative" because decomposition fluid cannot measure substance levels. The only evidence he was drunk is what the people who left him said.
Sources: ABC News, grand jury report, ABC News, July 27
His last hours
If this were a solved drowning
Accounted for
What the record actually says
Blank after 2:23 p.m. The last unlock of his phone is 2:18. The last video is 2:23. Everything after that is other people's word.
Sources: Mississippi Free Press, CNN timeline
The decision to stay
If this were a solved drowning
Confirmed
What the record actually says
Contradicted. Friends say he stayed for a young woman. The family says she told them he went back to the boat. In the chat, the friends themselves called the people around her "all so suspicious."
Sources: LAmag, Oxygen, ABC News, July 27
The evidence
If this were a solved drowning
Reviewed in full
What the record actually says
Disputed. The examiner says the DA got all 282 messages and the full data. The DA says she got a 300-page summary, not the 30-hour extraction. Snapchat's own records have never been subpoenaed, as far as the public record shows.
Sources: Mississippi Free Press
The conduct
We do not name them. They have not been charged, and people have been federally charged for threatening them. Their actions are a matter of record, and the record is what an investigation is for.
On the distress call to Sea Tow, the caller says about seven people are on the boat and all are accounted for. Nolan is not on the boat. It leaves at 4:31 without him.
Sources: PBS NewsHour, ABC News, July 27
The boat crawls nearly three miles at under 4.2 knots while a relative tells Sea Tow the problem is fixed. At 5:25 it runs at 30 to 35 knots and is home in 20 minutes. Three different accounts of who towed it.
Sources: ABC News, July 27, PBS NewsHour
The boat docks around 6. It is out of the water at the owner's house by 7:19. Nolan's parents get a call around 11. A call to the Coast Guard that night does not request its help.
Sources: CNN timeline
Between Nolan's last unlock and the moment his parents retrieve his phone, Snapchat messages in his group chats are deleted remotely by other users. Who, and what they said, is known only to Snapchat.
Sources: Mississippi Free Press
The day Nolan is found, the chat turns to how to handle police: "the smart move is to ask for an attorney," "Only facts," "just stick to what you know happened." Later: "We have nothing to hide."
Sources: Oxygen
The mother of one friend, a Jackson County chancery judge, posts the timeline that becomes the official story: last seen around 3, chose to stay, planned a ride with another group. The case is investigated and closed inside Jackson County.
Sources: TheGrio
The officials
These are public officials. They made these decisions in public, on the public's behalf, and they answer to the public. Their names, their decisions, and what they still owe Nolan's family.
Jackson County Sheriff's Office
What they did. Declared there were no signs of foul play on July 6, the day Nolan was found and before any autopsy. Said the investigation would be "thorough and factual." Never named a suspect, a person of interest, or an investigator.
What they owe his family. Explain what the July 6 finding of no foul play was based on. Release the investigative file now that the case is closed.
Sources: CNN timeline, TheGrio, July 14
Jackson County
What they did. Presented the case to a grand jury and declared it closed. Says her office received a 300-page summary from the family's examiner, not the full phone extraction. Says the family's team told her it had no evidence of a crime. Has not announced a subpoena for Snapchat's records.
What they owe his family. Subpoena Snapchat. Obtain and review the complete 30-hour extraction. Say publicly whether the other boats' GPS and the friends' phones were examined.
Sources: Mississippi Free Press, ABC News, grand jury report
State of Mississippi
What they did. Ruled the cause and manner of death undetermined. Found bruising on the back of the head it could not explain. Removed the lungs and neck structures before the independent pathologist could examine them.
What they owe his family. Release the full autopsy report and explain why the organs were not preserved for a second examination.
Sources: ABC News, Oct. 5, CNN timeline
State of Mississippi
What they did. Has the authority to review a county prosecution. Has made no public statement on Nolan's case.
What they owe his family. Say whether the state will review the county's handling of the case.
Sources: WLOX
State of Mississippi
What they did. Criticized the family's attorney on X and backed the county investigation while it was still open.
What they owe his family. Explain why the state backed the county's conclusions before the autopsy was complete.
Sources: CNN timeline
Where that leaves it
The grand jury's report says the case should be re-presented if credible evidence of a non-accidental death emerges. Mississippi has no statute of limitations on homicide. Horn Island is federal land. The evidence that could settle this exists. It has not been looked at by anyone outside Jackson County.
Sources: ABC News, grand jury report, ABC News, Oct. 5, WLOX
Join the movement
Officials count on families fighting alone. Join and get one five-minute action a week for Nolan and the other Mississippi cases, updates the moment something moves, and invitations to calls, vigils and events.
Fund the work
Support pays for records requests, independent experts and travel to stand with families. The Devin Kennedy Foundation is not yet a registered nonprofit, so gifts are not tax-deductible, and no money is collected in Nolan's name.
Give through PayPalThe Devin Kennedy
Foundation
Protect Mississippi's Children is a project of The Devin Kennedy Foundation.
About the foundation